| Year | 1st Team | 2nd Team | All-Dixie | All-State | All-Region | All-Regional Tournament | All-America |
| All-Dixie | All-Dixie | Tournament | SID Team | ||||
| 1985 | Michelle Masco (ss) | Michelle Hergenrother | Michelle Masco (ss) | ||||
| Lisa Gorby | |||||||
| Norine Davis | |||||||
| 1986 | Alisa Fox (ss) | Sandra Self | |||||
| Dawn Terry | |||||||
| Kim Saunders | |||||||
| 1987 | Evonne Bookwalter (3B) | ||||||
| Alisa Fox (ss) | |||||||
| Lisa Hayes (OF) | |||||||
| 1988 | none | ||||||
| 1989 | Sharon Ware (DH) | Cindy Greene (3B) | |||||
| Beth Trader (ss) | |||||||
| Demetra Saunders (c) | |||||||
| 1990 | Beth Trader (OF) | Jennifer Fields (1B) | Beth Trader (OF) | ||||
| Cindy Jones (P) | Jill Sagester (2B) | ||||||
| Kim Cason (3B) | |||||||
| Cindy Greene (SS) | |||||||
| Lisa Adams (DH) | |||||||
| 1991 | Jennifer Fields (DH) | Kim Cason (1B) | Mary Carpenter (P) | ||||
| Mary Carpenter (P) | Jennifer Bryant (OF) | Jennifer Fields (1B) | |||||
| Christy Byard (OF) | Kristi Milby (OF) | ||||||
| 1992 | Alecia Taverniti (2B) | Demetra Saunders (3B) | Kim Wells (C) | ||||
| Kim Wells (C) | Kinsey Pritchett (SS) | Rebecca Duckwall (OF) | |||||
| Jennifer Bryant (OF) | Rebecca Duckwall (OF) | Kinsey Pritchett (SS) | |||||
| Mary Carpenter (P -- Co MVP) | Patty Hooper (OF) | ||||||
| Bobby Wills (Co-Coach of the Year) | |||||||
| 1993 | Alecia Taverniti (2B) | Jennifer Fields (1B) | Jennifer Fields (1B -- MVP) | ||||
| Rebecca Ramirez (3B) | Alecia Taverniti (2B) | ||||||
| Kim Cason (3B) | Rebecca Ramirez (SS) | ||||||
| Kinsey Pritchett (OF) | Kinsey Pritchett (OF) | ||||||
| Rebecca Duckwall (OF) | |||||||
| Kerry Suniega (DH) | |||||||
| Neki Hunter (P) | |||||||
| Mary Carpenter (P) | |||||||
| Bobby Wills (Coach of the Year) | |||||||
| 1994 | Kerry Suniega (3B) | Kerri Cobb (2B) | Gretchen Farewell (SS) | ||||
| Gretchen Farewell (SS) | Cathy Riddick (C) | Cathy Riddick (C -- MVP) | |||||
| Kerri Cobb (P) | Jennifer Jerding (OF) | Kerri Cobb (P) | |||||
| Rebecca Duckwall (OF) | |||||||
| 1995 | Kerri Cobb (1B) | Kerri Cobb (1B) | Kerri Cobb (1st team P 1st team 1B) | Kerri Cobb (1st team-1st Base) | Kerri Cobb (3rd team 1st Base) | ||
| Cathy Riddick (C) | Cathy Riddick (C -- MVP) | Cathy Riddick (C) | Cathy Riddick (1st team C) | ||||
| Kerry Suniega (3B) | Jill Owens (P) | Jill Owens (HM -- P) | |||||
| Tara McClenney (OF) | Tara McClenney (HM -- OF) | ||||||
| Kerri Cobb (P) | |||||||
| Jill Owens (P) | |||||||
| Kerri Cobb (MVP) | |||||||
| 1996 | Cathy Riddick (C) | Joy Davison (2B) | Lori Terry (OF) | Jill Owens (1st Team P HM -- 1st) | Cathy Riddick (2nd team C) | ||
| Jill Owens (P) | Dee Shults (SS) | Jill Owens (2nd team P) | |||||
| Angie Raynes (DH) | Lori Terry (OF) | Lori Terry (3rd Team OF) | |||||
| 1997 | Jill Owens (P) | Heather Phillips (1B) | Jill Owens (P) | Jill Owens (P) | Jill Owens (P--2ndT) | ||
| Kati Minnick (3B) | Sarah Melton (OF) | Heather Morris (C--MVP) | Heather Phillips (1B) | Heather Emerson (DH--2ndT) | |||
| Dana Edwards (SS) | Jaci Morris (OF) | Kati Minnick (3B) | Heather Morris (C--3rdT) | ||||
| Dee Shults (OF) | Heather Emerson (DH) | Dana Edwards (SS--3rdT) | |||||
| Heather Emerson (DH) | Julie Shelton (P--2ndT) | ||||||
| Dee Shults (OF--2ndT) | |||||||
| 1998 | Dana Edwards (2B) | Jill Owens (1B) | Dee Shults (1B) | Jill Owens (1B)* | Jill Owens (Util) (First Team) |
Jill Owens (1B) | Jill Owens (Util) (Third Team) |
| Dee Shults (OF) | Kim Messick (OF) | Rachel Ward (2B) | Dana Edwards (SS) | Dana Edwards (SS) (First Team) | Dana Edwards (SS) | ||
| Jill Owens (P) | Heather Emerson (DH) | Dana Edwards (SS) | Dee Shults (OF) | Dee Shults (OF) (Second Team) | |||
| Staci Dodd (P) | Heather Emerson (DH) | Staci Dodd (P) (Third Team) | |||||
| 1999 | Kim Messick (OF) | Dee Shults (OF) | Crystal Bryant (3B) | Dee Shults (OF) | |||
| Tammi Perok (2B) | Andi McKenney (DH) | ||||||
| Crystal Bryant (3B) | |||||||
| 2000 | Stacey Hundley (SS) | Jen Harrell (1B) | Jennifer Nowacki (OF) | Donna Cerami (P) | Jen Harrell (1B) (2nd team) | ||
| Jennifer Nowacki (OF) | Crystal Storey (UT) | Stacey Hundley (SS) | Stacey Hundley (SS), (2nd team) | ||||
| Donna Cerami (P) | Jennifer Nowacki (HM) | Jennifer Nowacki (OF) (2nd team) | |||||
| Jen Harrell (HM) | Donna Cerami (P) (3rd team) | ||||||
| 2001 | Jen Harrell (1B) | Vanessa Gray (P) | Vanessa Gray (P) | Donna Cerami (P) | Donna Cerami (P) (2nd team) | ||
| Stacey Hundley (SS) | Dallas Slosjarik (OF) | Stacey Hundley (SS) | Jennifer Nowacki (HM) | Jen Harrell (1B) (2nd team) | |||
| Renee Sigafoos (C) | Donna Cerami (P) | Vanessa Gray (HM) | Stacey Hundley (SS) (2nd team) | ||||
| Jennifer Nowacki (OF) | Vanessa Gray (P) (3rd team) | ||||||
| Donna Cerami (P) | Jennifer Nowacki (OF) (3rd team) | ||||||
| Renee Sigafoos (C) (3rd team) | |||||||
| 2002 | Stacey Hundley (SS) | Vanessa Gary (3B) | Dallas Slosjarik (1st team OF) | ||||
| Dallas Slosjarik (OF) | Renee Sigafoos (C) | ||||||
| Vanessa Gray (P) | |||||||
| 2003 | Vanessa Gray (P) | Jen Harrell (1B) | Jen Harrell (1B) | Michelle Kass (P) (2nd team) | |||
| Michelle Kass (P) | Vanessa Gray (3B) | Dallas Slosjarik (OF) | Dallas Slosjarik (OF) (2nd team) | ||||
| Renee Sigafoos (C) | Michelle Kass (P) | Vanessa Gray (3rd team) | |||||
| Dallas Slosjarik (OF) | Jen Harrell (3rd team) | ||||||
| Renee Sigafoos (3rd team) | |||||||
| 2004 | Nicole Gray (2B) | ||||||
| C.J. McQueen (SS) | |||||||
| Andrea Rohde (C) | |||||||
| Renee Sigafoos (DH) | |||||||
| Dallas Slosjarik (OF) | |||||||
| Lauren Batson (OF) | |||||||
| Michelle Kass (P) | |||||||
| Vanessa Gray (P) |